Hands-on Review of Tamron 150-600 VC f/5-6.3

Lens Sharpness and Contrast
In my two ‘preview’ articles I showcased a number of images taken with the Tamron 150-600 with my D800. If you missed those preview articles or would like to view them again they can be found under the ‘Tamron’ category on this web site.

I found the image quality to be very good for a lens of this type. There is some softness at the 600mm end of the range, but it is quite common for a zoom lens to lose some sharpness at its longest focal length so this is not unexpected. Stopping down to f/8 does help to increase sharpness on the long end of the lens. The vast majority of people shooting with the Tamron SP 150-600 VC will shoot in RAW and apply some sharpening in post.

To give you an idea of jpeg sharpness, here is an out-of-camera jpeg taken at 600mm (EFoV 900mm) with my D800 in DX crop mode at f/8, 1/1600th, ISO-800. No adjustments have been made to this image, or the crop that follows it.

Tamron review Photo 10

And, here is a crop from the image above. Keep in mind that this level of cropping represents less than 5% of the total image area of my D800’s sensor.

Tamron review Photo 11

As a comparison here is an image taken at 600mm with my D800 in DX crop mode (EF0V 900mm) at f/8, 1/2000th , ISO-800. This image, as well as the crop that follows, were processed using the RAW file.

Tamron review Photo 12

Tamron review Photo 13

Image quality does improve when the lens is used below the 600mm maximum. Here is an image of a black crowned night heron taken in its nest with my D800 in DX crop mode. It was shot at 460mm (EFoV 690mm), f/8, 1/2000th, ISO-800.

Tamron review Photo 14

Here are two 100% crops from the above image.

Tamron review Photo 15

Tamron review Photo 16

Here is a night heron in flight that I captured with my D800 in DX crop mode. It was shot at 240mm (EFoV 360mm) at f/8, 1/1600th, ISO-400. The image was processed from a RAW file using DxOMark OpticsPro 8, CS6 and Nik Suite.

Tamron review Photo 17

To see more images of black crowned night herons taken with the Tamron SP 150-600 VC you can check out this YouTube video:

For those of you wondering about the image quality when using a cropped sensor body, here is a photo taken with a D7000 at an EFoV of 570mm, f/8, 1/640th , ISO-400.

Tamron review Photo 29

This is a 100% crop from the above image.

Tamron review Photo 30

This peacock image was taken with a D7000 at the Metro Toronto Zoo at an EFoV of 900mm, f/6.3, 1/200th , ISO-200.

Tamron review Photo 31

If you are wondering how well the Tamron SP 150-600 VC can capture fine detail, have a look at this image taken with my D800 in FX mode at 600mm, f/8, 1/1600th , ISO-400, -1 EV. You’ll notice a fly on the white flower.

Tamron review Photo 32

Now have a look at a 100% crop taken from the image above. The fly was 8.4 meters, or about 27.5 feet, away from me.

Tamron review photo 33

This photograph of a dandelion seed head was taken with my D800 in DX crop mode, EFoV of 900mm, f/6.3 1/1250th, ISO-3200.

Tamron review photo 34

Here are a few more images of birds taken with the Tamron SP 150-600 VC using my D800 in DX crop mode. This next image was taken at an EFoV of 900mm, f/7.1, 1/2000th, ISO-800.

Tamron review Photo 35

This cormorant was shot at an EFoV of 450mm, f/8, 1/2500th, ISO-800.

Tamron review Photo 36

The flying gull photo below was taken at an EFoV of 450mm, f/8, 1/200th, ISO-800.

Tamron review Photo 37

This stationary gull was shot with an EFoV of 900mm, f/8, 1/6400th, ISO-800.

Tamron review Photo 38

The majority of users should find the image quality of the Tamron 150-600 VC to be more than acceptable. Obviously having realistic expectations of a lens costing about $1,100 US is needed, and not being an obsessive pixel peeper would also be a plus.

f/8, 1/2000, ISO-400, 500mm (efov 750mm)
f/8, 1/2000, ISO-400, 500mm (efov 750mm)

The Tamron 150-600 does incorporate eBAND and BBAR coatings to help reduce lens flare and ghosting. I did shoot the Tamron quite a bit without the lens hood and I did not find any issues with lens flare. Overall, I found the image quality to be quite good in terms of colour rendition and contrast.

8 thoughts on “Hands-on Review of Tamron 150-600 VC f/5-6.3”

  1. Good afternoon Thomas …. your work is stunning! I am considering buying a 160-600mm lens a cannot find any comparisons between the Tamron VC and the new Sigma contemporary lenses. The Sigma Sport is out of my range …. cameras Nikon D700 and D750. I would appreciate your advice and guidance. Thanks a million. Regards JJ (South Africa)

    1. Hi Johan,
      Thank you for your kind words, they are much appreciated! I haven’t seen anything on the Sigma Contemporary yet so I don’t have much guidance to provide on that particular lens. As far as the Tamron 150-600, I don’t think you should have any issues with your D750…your D700 may have a bit of focus lag since it is an older body. The Sigma Sport is a very nice lens, but at almost twice the price as the Tamron I really didn’t see enough of a difference in image quality to warrant the additional money, especially if both lenses are shot at f/8.
      Tom

  2. cjbayliss, I have both the Nikon 500 f4G and 600 f4G but I had the 500 f4D. You’ll love that lens as it is only a bit slower than the G series. I’m also now looking into the 300 f4 newest edition as I understand its performance with all three Nikon TC’s are great.

    With that in mind, Thomas, this is a great practical review with real photos instead of MTF charts. I particularly enjoy your writing style because it is most like sitting with another photographer just shooting the breeze about something fantastic he found. I work with students and this is the way I like to teach; except for a few basic fundamentals.

    I like zooms and was going to pull the trigger on the Tamron as I’ve only heard good things from realistic photographers regarding this lens. However, I am waiting for the Sigma 150-600 to come out to see if there will be a significant difference.

    1. Hi Mike,

      Thanks for the positive comment – much appreciated! This is the approach I intend on using for all of my articles here…folks can find MTF charts on lots of other sites.

      Sigma has two 150-600 zooms that you can consider. The Sport version was introduced first and Sigma is positioning it as ‘pro’ glass. It is about double the price of the Tamron 150-600 and also weighs about 1 Kg more…a little over 2 pounds heavier. I haven’t seen many reviews of the Sport lens yet as Sigma called back their early production due to some quality issues that have not been detailed. The other Sigma 150-600 lens is the Contemporary version. The price hasn’t been announced but it appears to be targeted directly at the Tamron offering in terms of size, and I would imagine closer in price as well. Since I really don’t like to use tripods I think the Sigma Sport would be too heavy for my style of shooting.

      Here is a link to one of the few comparisons that I’ve seen: http://www.kruger-2-kalahari.com/tamron-vs-sigma-150-600.html

      The new Nikkor 300mm f/4 looks like it could be a really great lens. Small, light, sharp, and likely works very well with teleconverters…what else could a shooter want?

      Tom

  3. G’day Thomas!

    I’ve read this article before, but I’m glad I read it again. Currently I’m looking at getting a Nikkor 500mm F4D AF-S, and I’ve been a bit unsure. But now I think I’ll get it. It is super clear, and F4 at 500 is really nice.

    Anyway, I like your blog! It looks great on my iPhone.

    I really appreciate your photography, and the time you spend helping people. Keep it up mate! 🙂

    Christopher

    1. Hi Christopher,

      Glad you like the new blog! The 500mm f/4 sounds like an amazing lens…I’m sure you’ll do some cracker-jack work with it. I just read that Nikon announced a 300mm f/4 today that sounds like a superb lens as well.

      Tom

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *